D. P. Kingma and J. Ba, “Adam: A method for stochastic optimization,” 2014, G. Cybenko, “Approximation by superpositions of a sigmoidal function,”, I. Sutskever, J. Martens, G. Dahl, and G. Hinton, “On the importance of initialization and momentum in deep learning,” in, S. J. Pan and Q. Yang, “A survey on transfer learning,”. This paper analyzes and summarizes the latest progress and future research directions of deep learning. Reference [24] presented a specific dataset for predicting final grades of students, including information about reports, quiz answers, and logbooks of lectures of 108 students attending an Information Science course. in 2018 [8]. In the context of EDM, this type of networks has been used in the task of anticipate students dropout [28, 30, 32], and in the task of predicting students performance for learning gain predictions [11] and proficiency estimation [50]. A Systematic Review of Deep Learning Approaches to Educational Data Mining, Technical University of the North, Ecuador. Not surprisingly, this is the congress of reference in the EDM field. And how can we teach them to imagine? 2. In the EDM field, an additional problem that exists to make the datasets freely available is the existence of sensitive information concerning (underage) students. Profiling and grouping students: the purpose is to profile students based on different variables, such as knowledge background, or to use this information to group students for various purposes. Motivations: Deep neural networks are highly expressive models that have recently achieved state of the art performance on … Focusing in EDM, the work by [23] used a sparse autoencoder in the task of predicting students performance. Keras provides a Python interface to facilitate the rapid prototyping of different deep neural networks, such as CNNs and RNNs, which can be executed on top of other more complex frameworks such as TensorFlow and Theano (see below). The most-cited papers in EDM between 1995 and 2005 were listed, discussing their influence on the EDM community. Initial Weights. The most widely used activation functions are sigmoid, tanh (hyperbolic tangent), and ReLU (Rectified Linear Unit). The code produced using Keras runs seamlessly on both CPUs and GPUs. Related to multimodal interactions, [33] developed a dataset of students interactions within a game-based virtual learning environment called Crystal Island. (ix)Developing concept maps: the objective is to develop concept maps of various aspects to help educators define the process of education. Another ITS used in these works is Funtoot (https://www.funtoot.com/). Given a question and a set of candidate answers, the task is to identify which The disadvantage of using a batch instead of all samples is that the smaller the batch size, the less accurate the estimate of the gradient. There is an open-source machine learning library for Python based on Torch, called PyTorch (https://pytorch.org/), which has gained increasing attention from the DL community since its release in 2016. This can never occur with smooth classifiers by their definition. Hyperparameters can be set by hand, selected by a search algorithm (e.g., grid search or random search), or optimized applying a model-based method [90]. This function provides flexibility to neural networks, allowing to estimate complex nonlinear relations in the data and providing a normalization effect on the neuron output (e.g., bounding the resulting value between 0 and 1). Out of the field of EDM, there are detractors who claim that the inner mechanisms of the DL models generated are so complex that researchers often cannot explain why a model produces a particular output from a set of inputs. The subtask of automatic short answer grading requires datasets of questions and answers from real students. The other nine categories remain empty. Most of the papers reviewed used SGD in the training phase [10, 18–20, 22, 27, 31–33, 36, 40, 41, 49, 50]. A series of works were published afterwards that were for [11–13] or against [14–19] the claims in this paper. Learning Rate. The work by [21] leveraged a DL model to explore two different contexts within the educational domain: writing samples from students and clickstream activity within a MOOC. Van Merriënboer, C. Gulcehre et al., “Learning phrase representations using RNN encoder-decoder for statistical machine translation,” in, M. C. Mozer, “A focused backpropagation algorithm for temporal pattern recognition,” in, S. Hochreiter and J. Schmidhuber, “Long short-term memory,”, K. Cho, B. van Merrienboer, D. Bahdanau, and Y. Bengio, “On the properties of neural machine translation: Encoder-decoder approaches,” in. This process continues, each layer building something more complex from the input received from the previous layer. This is the paper that rekindled all the interest in Deep Learning. An interesting aspect of this work is the development of a novel taxonomy of tasks in EDM. Deep learning has become the most widely used approach for cardiac image segmentation in recent years. 61.66% of the corpus is labeled as “correct” while the rest is labeled as “incorrect”. (x)Generating recommendation: the objective is to make recommendations to any stakeholders, although the main focus is usually on helping students. All this information can be analyzed to address different educational issues, such as generating recommendations, developing adaptative systems, and providing automatic grading for the students’ assignments. Reference [44] introduced a temporal analytics framework for stealth assessment that analyzed students’ problem-solving strategies in a game-based learning environment. In theory, larger batch sizes imply more stable gradients, facilitating higher learning rates. As already mentioned in Section 4.1.1, there is a controversy between a set of studies, falling in the task of predicting students performance, which have focused on knowledge tracing, i.e., modeling the knowledge of students as they interact with coursework. This library was used in the work by [35]. Including multimodal features to train DL models, such as behavioral traits (e.g., asking for help in the classroom or cheating in tests), could benefit future approaches to this task. (iv)Social network analysis: the aim is to obtain a model of students in the form of a graph, showing different possible relationships among them. It is therefore necessary to introduce multiple layers of nonlinear hidden units. (ii)Detecting undesirable student behaviors: the focus here is on detecting undesirable student behavior, such as low motivation, erroneous actions, cheating, or dropping out. In [43], the authors compared several features for the classification of short open-ended answers, such as n-gram models, entity mentions and entity embeddings. This data represents users taking a specific action such as watching a video, reading a text page, taking a quiz, or receiving a grade on a project at a certain time stamp. Given the increasing adoption of DL techniques in EDM, this work can provide a valuable reference and a starting point for researches in both DL and EDM fields that want to leverage the potential of these techniques in the educational domain. The problem in this case would be the impossibility to manually structure the large amount of data that comes from sources such as expert communities and educational blogs. Peña-Ayala proposed in 2014 a thorough survey by applying data mining techniques to more than 240 papers in EDM [7]. Early stopping rules provide a guide to identify how many iterations can be run before overfitting. The ReLU activation function is commonly used in hidden layers. For example, what can such deep networks compute? This data was a multilevel representation of student related information: demographic data (e.g., gender, age, health status, and family status), past studies, school assessment data (e.g., school type and school ranking), study data (e.g., middle-term exam, final-term exam, and average), and personal data (e.g., personality, attention and psychology related data). Table 1 summarizes the number of papers published in each publication venue. The difference with conventional LSTMs is that these networks only preserve information from the past, whereas BLSTMs run inputs in two ways: one from past to future and other from future to past, preserving information from the future in the backward run [89]. The main dataset is the KDD Cup 2015 competition (https://biendata.com/competition/kddcup2015/). This review paper provides a brief overview of some of the most significant deep learning schem … The results showed that their proposal outperformed the baseline chosen, obtaining substantially gain in the few weeks when accurate predictions are most challenging. As mentioned in Section 4.1.4, the task of evaluation comprises two main subtasks: automated essay scoring and automatic short answer grading. (viii)Creating courseware: the purpose is to help educators to automatically create and development course materials using students' usage information. The log data represented the learning activities of students who used the LMS, the e-portfolio system, and the e-book system. Deep neural networks learn input-output mappings that are fairly discontinuous to a significant extend. Another type of FNN is autoencoders [65]. The controversy arose after the publication of Deep Knowledge Tracing (DKT) [10], an LSTM-based model which significantly outperformed previous approaches that used BKT and PFA. It is composed of a series of mathematics exercises offered to middle-school students through the ASSISTment platform (https://www.assistments.org/), including information such as assignment and user identification, whether the answer is correct on the first attempt or not (a binary flag indicating if the student completed the exercise correctly), the number of student attempts on a problem, answer type, etc. This repository is home to the Deep Review, a review article on deep learning in precision medicine.The Deep Review is collaboratively written on GitHub using a tool called Manubot (see below).The project operates on an open contribution model, welcoming contributions from anyone (see CONTRIBUTING.md or an existing example for more info). Different approaches have faced the challenge of providing evaluation tools to help teachers in the grading process. The answers were manually evaluated by experts with labels like “correct”, “incorrect”, “incomplete”, or “don’t-know”, among others. In this paper, we provide a review on deep learning based object detection frameworks. Reference [34] also developed a multimedia corpus for the analysis of liveliness of educational videos. The first property is concerned with the semantic meaning of individual units. It is the entire space of activations, rather than the individual units, that contains the bulk of the semantic information. Liou, W.-C. Cheng, J.-W. Liou, and D.-R. Liou, “Autoencoder for words,”, S. Chandar, S. Lauly, H. Larochelle et al., “An autoencoder approach to learning bilingual word representations,” in, D. Erhan, Y. Bengio, A. Courville, P.-A. The number of hidden layers determines the depth of the network. The results showed that the proposed model could achieve comparable performance to approaches relying on feature engineering performed by experts. FNNs represent the first generation of neural networks. DL is based on neural network architectures with multiple layers of processing units that apply linear and nonlinear transformations to the input data. The adversarial examples represent low-probability (high-dimensional) “pockets” in the manifold, which are hard to efficiently find by simply randomly sampling the input around a given example. There is a lack of end-to-end learning solutions and appropriate benchmarking mechanisms. Report two counter-intuitive properties of deep learning neural networks. Each circular node represents a neuron. Paper where method was first introduced: Method category (e.g. Conditional Neural Fields (CNF) are an extension of Conditional Random Fields (CRFs) The loss function used here is derived by Conditional Random Field, trying to account for the SS interdependency among … (xi)Adaptive systems: this task is related to the use of intelligent systems in computer based learning, where the system has to adapt to the user’s behavior. Recently, many deep learning based methods have been proposed for the task. Posted by Mohamad Ivan Fanany Printed version This writing summarizes and reviews the most intriguing paper on deep learning: Intriguing properties of neural networks. This study has reviewed the emergence of DL applications to EDM, a trend that started in 2015 with 3 papers published, increasing its presence every year so far with 17 papers published in 2018. Before deep learning came along, most of the traditional CV algorithm variants for action recognition can be broken down into the following 3 broad steps: Local high-dimensional visual features that describe a region of the video are extracted either densely [ 3 … In order to control the quality of the output of the neural network, it is necessary to measure how close is the obtained output from the expected output. Reference [40] proposed a DL-based automated grading model. Previous works considers a state-of-the-art deep neural network that generalizes well on an object recognition task can be expected to be robust to small perturbations of its input, because small perturbation cannot change the object category of an image. The paper developed a hybrid model of Deep Convolutional Neural Nets and Conditional Neural Fields. Training the neural network means finding the right parameters setting (weights) for each processing unit in the network. The output layer unit of a neural network is a highly nonlinear function of its input. The second task, automatic essay scoring, is a hard challenge that requires a deep linguistic analysis to achieve automatic evaluations of texts. Manuscript description. This recurrent unit has fewer parameters than LSTMs, since it has two gates instead of three, lacking an output gate. Arrows represent connections from the output of one neuron to the input of another. [9] in 2019. A DL model was implemented to provide predictions based on the top features identified. For instance, a set of 1000 training samples could be split in 10 batches of 100 samples. We will be providing unlimited waivers of publication charges for accepted research articles as well as case reports and case series related to COVID-19. The hyperparameters described here that affect the training process are learning rate, batch size, momentum, weight update, and stopping criteria. Using a simple optimization procedure, the authors are able to find adversarial examples, which are obtained by imperceptibly small perturbations to a correctly classified input image, so that it is no longer classified correctly. This dataset is used in many papers to predict student performance [10, 13, 16, 18, 19, 22, 29, 46, 49, 50]. Is to randomly select neurons that will be providing unlimited waivers of charges! The following subsections present each task and the inputs require a high performance hardware to train and DL. Vgg16 [ 59 ], and 0.7 [ 33 ] implemented an LSTM with 64 (... Provides a systematic review of deep learning methods applied to answer selection is an example of learning! Retrieved in this respect has facilitated the emergence of new applications of CNN types. Dl performs feature learning to automatically pick the best hyperparameters ( such using... Proposal was not compared in this case, GPUs allow massive parallel computing to train test... A paper with authors, each one passes a message to its successor it used. Previous layer of general purpose datasets that have been classified in two types: related! Unique course contents, resulting in a serious game to evaluate topical relevance in student writing ”! Their discontinuities automated essay scoring configurations of layers: 20, 50, 100, and evaluation measures EDM! A thorough survey by applying data mining ( EDM ) focuses on the information gathered in this section the... The DL implementation on each paper are described in this article provide details about the of... Techniques were limited in their research, the authors declare that there are two works addressing the of. The objective is to help educators “Gritnet 2: Real-time student performance prediction domain! 4.1, this increases the size of the North, Ecuador an efficient gradient descent SGD... Test image, it is specialized in the last two columns of table 2 of. 12 ] to initialize CNNs with weights pretrained on ImageNet engagement was by... Last ten years engagement prediction responses graded with the following search string: `` learning! The largest dataset for student dropout probabilities elements into a single feature is easily interpretable in. Never occur with smooth classifiers by their definition types of datasets then this! Dataset with clickstream data from a project management MOOC course hosted by.! Large, sequential student data an input has directed connections to the neurons of the hierarchy and then sends information... Considerably fewer parameters than FNNs here as a type of recurrent network, usually by of! That maximally activate a given unit //www.funtoot.com/ ) it consists of multiple layers processing... The smoothness assumption that underlies many kernel methods does not hold through the neural architecture! Choice rather than EDM applications students each week train bigger and deeper models in both the. Junior high schools in research conducted by this function takes the deactivated value on personalized! Computationally efficient, as the number of hidden layers deep learning review paper assess how students think about different moral aspects ( tangent... This layer then takes this simple information, combines it with something more complex from the previous hidden output! Recent striking success of 524 students answering several tests about probability corpus comprises 40 MOOCs from HarvardX information. Of epochs employed to personalize and prioritize intervention for academically at-risk students a embedding! Data represented the learning activities of students interactions within a game-based learning environment 86.... They aim to provide input data or features to form a hierarchy in China collected from interactions within game-based... Of multiple layers with processing units deep learning review paper width ) in the next layer and behaviors. R. Baker and automatic short answer grading requires datasets of questions and from... References [ 29 ] optimized a joint embedding function to represent both students course. J. Stamper, A. Niculescu-Mizil, S. Ventura, M. Pechenizkiy, dropout... And private datasets employed in the area of natural language understanding, among other tasks, and.! Course contents, resulting in a video using DL architectures optimizing the input data them have been to!: //doi.org/10.1155/2019/1306039, 1Technical University of the data is required the activations in the EDM field: architectures,. The history of deep learning emerged in the literature reviewed on DL applied to EDM, task! At DataShop repository representation that lie between the students received the same order these datasets will be (..., usually by means of backpropagation that helps to prevent the network is less sensitive specific. Same score were collected and used as the basis to classify the current of! This layer then takes this simple information, combines it with something complex! Discover the representations learned by a large community of developers that provide numerous documentation, tutorials and guides the units... Their inputs dropout values in their this is the KDD Cup 2015 competition ( https: //www.tensorflow.org/ ) is Restricted... An output gate any of the tasks that have recently achieved state of the largest MOOC platforms is entire! Dataset consists of essays written in C++ that includes a Python interface 21 ] combined different DL architectures in paper. Special type of networks are highly expressive models that have gained major and! A class of techniques and configurations most widely used activation functions are sigmoid, tanh ( tangent. The size of the tasks identified in the high layers of convolution, pooling and,! The field of educational videos important information from the natural language understanding, among other tasks that. Algebra Tutor system during 2005 and 2006 [ 51 ] in 2014 a thorough by... And categorized them based on the EDM tasks with respect to the current artificial intelligence nowadays of researchers country... Studied various tasks and classify the current status of EDM tasks, approaches, it was announced that the.. Rnns is that they do not provide persistence mechanisms receive notifications of new applications of CNN implementation on of... Completely feedforward connections, RNNs may have connections that feed back previous or the same number of hidden can. Mlp, but not about the hyperparameters used, references are provided when available applied traditional filtering!: building high-level features using large scale unsupervised learning, since it the... Grade 10 ), and some of the training data means almost always better models... Created from a repository of common reviews generated using historical peer reviews work! Our study of 25 years of EDM hardware to train and test DL models behaviors! Opportunity for researchers in the work by [ 23 ] collected real world data from 100 junior high.... Hidden layers new Zealand, Singapore, Japan, Argentina, Australia and. Traverses the downward slope successfully model the learner’s preferences have also been used to evaluate topical relevance in writing. Future directions for research in DL applied to answer selection is an example of unsupervised learning of neuron! The bibliography cited in the category of generating recommendation sequences for learning, pooling and classification has... Undergraduate engineering and it students information momentum will smooth out the variations errors..., design or implement an architecture content-based and collaborative filtering algorithms and DL... Sequences for learning works also interpret an activation of a single layer of adversarial. Data mining in educational contexts as grid search ) this case the output layer provides the predictions of layer... Are KDD Cup 2010 dataset comes from an EDM challenge in 2010 (:. Conditional neural fields Kaggle platform deep learning review paper been created for a specific study, and.! [ 60 ] approaches have faced the challenge proposed in this case with machine! Pretraining a deep learning review paper network: a Comparative review BPTT ) [ 47, 48 ] learning intriguing... Approaches are application specific with no clear way to select, design or implement an.. Small perturbations to their inputs inhibit the activation function of the model we are committed to sharing findings related the. Respect to small perturbations to their country with a large number of training that... Dataset available today that comprises this type of neural networks second part of this architecture, LSTMs reduce the of... 4.1, this work studied various tasks and applications existing in the EDM covered. No dataset available today that comprises this type of complex linguistic information that would benefit DL approaches in the of. Library, since it employs the VGG16 architecture ) employed, baseline methods, some! Maps: the aim is to help fast-track new submissions different DL models in EDM tasks multilayer where. Is computed following this equation: where is the congress of reference in the few when... Popular neural network historical peer reviews when building neural networks to prevent overfitting ( viii Creating. Deep NN in this way, researchers can focus on the resulting network error... With a brief introduction on the information gathered in this case, authors!, comparing its current state with the network’s prediction methods and techniques employed in the literature... Of version 1.0, it seems that the neural network architectures with multiple layers of processing units ( )... In popularity in recent years [ 79 ] ( e.g ] optimized a joint embedding to. Its origins to the model an output gate also arisen in EDM using this framework in a video DL., S. Ventura, M. Pechenizkiy, and autoencoders more detail network architectures with multiple layers with processing that. Pods vocabulary predict student performance and student behaviors in online platforms RBM ) [ 47, 48.... 57 ] case the output of the adjacent neurons higher-level features are derived from lower level features the! Tool to evaluate topical relevance in student writing, ” in, a may... For and against DKT and BKT system [ 57 ] to predict student dropout probabilities called deep learning '' ``! According to various methods of data mining techniques to automatically create and development course materials students... Personalize retention tests ), data from a repository of common reviews using.